Carol Ann Wilson
HOUSE OF MIRRORS
Published in The Awakenings Review
The Awakenings Review publishes poets, writers and artists experiencing mental illnesses, and related writers. It is a print-only journal, but you can see a sample in this PDF file.
Throughout psychiatry’s history, its view of delusions has centered on their imperviousness to contrary evidence. In Kraepelin’s influential (1899) textbook Psychiatry, he writes that a delusion is a belief that is not open to doubt. (K. Arnold & J. Vakhrusheva, 2015)
It was mid-October 2008 and our last evening in Italy after spending several weeks in the Chianti countryside. With an overnight stay in the fishing village of Fiumicino near the Rome airport, we slept unaware of what was happening at home in Colorado.
Back in Boulder, through the fog of jet lag, I checked my email messages, something I hadn’t been able to do consistently in Italy. And there on my screen was a message from Vandy, a friend who had been restoring a small building at Stillpoint, our beloved property in the mountains. She had written it October 6, more than a week earlier.
Hi Carol,
I want you to know that we did not end up camping at Stillpoint last weekend. We arrived at the property and encountered a man who said he was the owner. He was not familiar with your name. After a short conversation with him we left. I felt as though the person we met did not belong there and thought you should know. He said that he planned to stay until November or so.
Reading that, I got on the phone with our good friend and observant neighbor who lives two miles up the road. He told me he’d seen a pickup parked by the barn cabin for the last few weeks and figured it belonged to someone we knew because it had been there a while. “If you don’t know who’s there,” he said, “you should call the sheriff.”
The sheriff’s office is in Westcliffe, the small town twenty-two miles west of Stillpoint. I spoke with Deputy Boyd Rafferty there, who said he and another officer would go check it out immediately.
A few hours later, Deputy Rafferty phoned to tell me they had the man in custody. “Unfortunately, we had to break the door down to get to him.”
A jolt of adrenalin hit me, followed by a wave of dismay, then intense curiosity. This happening at Stillpoint? The physical damage was one thing, but the brute force needed to break through the door was an entirely different matter. Why would they have to do that? Who was this guy?
Stillpoint, as the name suggests, is a quiet place, a beautiful place. We loved being there. It was our place to tune out the rest of the world, relax, read, walk, and take life more slowly than town usually allowed. And the cabin—an old barn, the top half of which long ago held bales of hay, was now a comfortable retreat. The sturdy front door featured a large pane of glass, making it easy to see inside. But first you had to pass through the metal storm door that enclosed a porch we used as a mudroom. It was usually left unlocked.
Deputies Rafferty and Tina King had first checked a guest cabin that sits about a third of a mile into the property, where Vandy had seen the man. They could see it had been forcefully entered and some books and other objects strewn around, but no one was there. They drove back to the road and up the driveway to the main cabin.
As the two deputies approached the property entrance, they spotted the pick-up parked by the cabin. Deputy King approached the mudroom door with caution and found it locked from the inside. The two decided she would walk around the immediate exterior of the cabin, while Rafferty explored the perimeter. As King moved east, Rafferty moved around to the west side and saw a man looking through the blinds. Bearded, and with fairly long hair, his face looked angry and agitated. Rafferty shouted for him to come out, but the man backed away from the window. Rafferty moved back and took cover behind the vehicles.
King, at the back of the cabin and under an open window, heard a male voice. She couldn’t tell if he was talking to someone in the house or on the phone. Or to himself. She tried calling dispatch and, despite the difficulty of making radio contact in that mountainous area, she managed to connect to tell them someone was in the house but refused to come out.
Pressing her body against the wall, she listened to the voice above. She thought she heard the man saying there were armed deputies outside and that they should know that he knew the sheriff, as well as the Pueblo County sheriff. Puzzled, King asked dispatch to find out if he was on the phone with the Pueblo County sheriff. They responded that they, Custer County dispatch, had received a 911 call and were in fact talking with him at that moment.
He told them he was employed by the FBI and other government agencies and that he was not to go out of the house at the direction of law enforcement without at least three FBI agents present to give him approval. As Deputy Rafferty was relating all this to me, he paused for a moment at that point, took a breath, and then he told me the man actually said, “If you call John Kerry or George W, you will realize this is all a tragic mistake.”
I couldn’t stifle my burst of laughter.
Eventually, the undersheriff and a sergeant arrived and then the Fremont County SWAT team. Trying to coax the man out, an officer shouted, “We’re with the sheriff’s department and we want you to come out. We won’t harm you.”
Again they called out to him, identifying themselves and telling him to unlock the door. Several attempts later, they realized he wasn’t going to comply, leaving them with few options. After consulting with each other, one of the officers heaved himself at the large wooden door. With a loud crack, it broke from the frame.
As Rafferty described this turn of events, I felt a wrenching inside my stomach. In my mind’s eye, I could see the door, feel the force. Who was that man inside our cabin? How could this have happened?
The shattered doorframe now behind them, the officers stood, taking in the scene and focusing on the bearded man. He stood in the far corner of the room. His eyes riveted on them, he shouted, “Stop, or I’ll shoot!” and came toward them. As if it were a gun, he pointed the phone handset straight at them.
They spoke quietly to the man, whom I’ll call Dan Gray, managing to calm him. Then Rafferty began the questions.
“Do you know Carol Wilson?”
“Oh, yes,” Gray replied. “She worked for me, but I had to let her go because I couldn’t pay her.”
“So, is this your property?”
“Yes, I own all the land around here,” Gray said, waving his hand toward the large fields across and up the road. “I have a contract with the USDA for the grain I’m growing out there. I have to keep things quiet, because big secrets are involved.”
Eager to continue, he said, “I’m an agent for the FBI, and I have fighter planes down in the basement. That’s classified information. I’m following secret orders from George Bush and Al Gore. They’re working together on this.”
Eventually, Rafferty arrested Gray, handcuffing him and taking him out of the house to the sheriff’s vehicle. Although he went willingly, Gray still tried to explain. “This is all a big mistake. I work for the government. I’ve just recently returned from an assignment in China. If you call either Senator Kerry or President Bush, they will vouch for me and explain the whole situation.”
He added, “I own all the hay fields southeast of here. They’re quite large, extensive hay fields, and I’m leasing them to the DEA.”
“Why would the DEA be leasing hay fields?” Rafferty asked.
“Because it’s hay season,” Gray replied.
After the arrest, I heard little for a while, other than Gray was from Pueblo, thirty miles away, where his parents also lived. According to someone who knew him, he’d been an excellent auto mechanic until a few years before. Then he’d been diagnosed with schizophrenia and had to be on medications to manage it. I wondered if maybe he’d stopped taking the meds. Regardless, he would have to be assessed to see if and when he was mentally competent to stand trial.
The story suggesting a normal, everyday guy going about his life until this disorder struck confused me, raising questions I’d never considered before. He had parents. What were they like? How were they reacting? How must they feel with their son in jail? He’d had a job at which he excelled. What happened? And why, if medications helped, would he not take them—if that were, in fact, the case? There was so much I didn’t know, and because my life was overly full of work, family, and other pursuits at the time, I didn’t try to find out. Only much later would I read Elyn Saks’s account of her own struggle with schizophrenia. “With psychosis, the wall that separates fantasy from reality dissolves; inside my head, the fantasies were real, and everything was actually happening. The images I saw, the actions I took, were all real, and it made me frantic.”
The October 16th issue of Westcliffe’s weekly Wet Mountain Tribune carried the following notice under the “Sheriff’s Blotter;” it was titled “In the Hoosegow.”
. . . On Oct. 13, deputies arrested [Daniel Gray], 44, of Pueblo, and charged him with second degree burglary, impersonating a police officer, false reporting to a police officer, refusing to leave property when ordered and obstructing a police officer. [He] was booked into the Custer County jail on a no bond hold. He was expected to appear in court on Wednesday, Oct. 15. The arrest stems from a report in which it was believed [he] was living in a home near Wetmore without permission. When authorities arrived, [he] refused to open the door and he claimed he was an FBI agent. Deputies broke into the home and arrested him without incident.
The break-in created a sense of vulnerability for us. For seventeen years, we’d left a set of keys inside a small jug in the mudroom for friends to have easy access to the cabin. We’d never encountered a problem of any kind. Now we felt we needed to do a little more about security.
A few days after the arrest, I drove the one-hundred-fifty miles from Boulder to Stillpoint to see for myself what Dan Gray had left behind and to meet the locksmith, who was to change all the locks. We were also putting a chain and lock on each of the three entry gates into the property and had requested a house-watch check from the sheriff’s department. This meant that when out on patrol, officers would make a concerted effort to look for anything unusual at Stillpoint.
At the cabin, I stood facing, not the front door, but a large piece of plywood nailed across the opening where the door had been. A sense of violation swept through me, burrowing into the pit of my stomach. Stillpoint had always been a source of solace, so very different from this unsettling feeling of intrusion.
Climbing the back stairs to the deck, I entered the cabin through the kitchen door and stood motionless, breathless. Chaos lay before me. Blankets, pillows, dishtowels, and clothes were strewn across the sofa. Our blankets. Our pillows and dishtowels. A large, brightly colored, fish-shaped tray we’d bought in the Baja balanced atop the old walnut sideboard, far from its place in the kitchen. The small television on which we occasionally watched videos and was normally tucked in a bedroom closet now sat in the middle of the floor, large pieces of aluminum foil affixed to its antenna. Video tapes, cassette tapes, DVDs and CDs lay in myriad stacks across the old piano.
Throughout the cabin, furniture sat in odd places and pictures hung on different walls. In the kitchen area, the double sink overflowed with bottles, jars, dishes, and plastic bags. Someone had told me Gray had poured the alcohol he’d found—brandy, a bottle of vodka a friend had brought from Mongolia, some liqueurs—into his truck’s gas tank, wrongly thinking it would serve as fuel. Those bottles lay in the heap of stuff in the sink, and his truck sat immobile outside.
Disoriented, I could think only of a house of mirrors, where every shape was distorted, appearances out of whack. There seemed little rhyme or reason for the placement of objects, and the fusty smell and overall squalor only added to a sense of unreality.
When the deputies arrested Gray, they had checked the place over and found no working faucets. We later determined that a breaker on the pump had flipped, which partly explained the piles of dirty dishes, the unflushed toilet and the other messes they’d found. Apparently, in search of water, Gray had broken into the community house, which we’d built a few years before to accommodate university groups that used Stillpoint for wilderness experiences as part of their curriculum. A kitchen and two sets of bathrooms, each with two sinks, two toilets, and two showers were handy amenities for guests. Gray had found an open window in the bathroom adjacent to the kitchen and, not finding water there, had cut a hole in the wall to the kitchen, but to no avail. He hadn’t known the problem was a flipped breaker, nor had he known where to go to correct the problem.
Weeks passed, then months. Gray underwent periodic evaluations, all determining that he was not mentally competent to stand trial. And then one day, I received a subpoena to testify in the Custer County court on January 26, 2010, a year and three months after the break-in.
For moral support, three friends who lived in the area and knew Stillpoint well went with me to the trial. In the car on the way to Westcliffe, we joked about the situation, something I’d been doing since it had happened. The things Gray had said seemed so incongruous and outlandish, they seemed to invite mirth. They certainly didn’t fit into any cognitive framework I had.
“Jets in the basement.” We all laughed. “And I was supposedly working for him? At least he didn’t say he fired me for poor performance!”
“Well, how about George W and Al Gore working together on this secret operation? And John Kerry, too!”
“That phone weapon he had. Can’t you just imagine him saying, ‘Stop—
or I’ll put you on speaker phone!”
It would be only a few hours later that I would think about how easily we joke about things we don’t understand, situations and people who don’t fit into the way we think the world works—people we label as “other.” I would wonder why so much humor comes from someone else’s misfortune. And I would consider explanations I’ve heard: that we laugh at others’ difficulties to counteract our own fight or flight response; we joke to quiet the false alarm our ancient brain sets off; or perhaps we’re laughing at a repressed, disassociated aspect of ourselves. We joke to make ourselves less uncomfortable.
But at what price?
I was already seated when a guard escorted Gray into the court room. Wearing handcuffs and orange clothing, he shuffled to the seat designated for him and sat down. His head hung low and his body slumped forward as if he were a rag doll. I sat some twenty feet behind him and to the side so that I could see his profile, but not his whole face. Even so, his body seemed like an empty shell.
I was shocked. This was the man who had broken into Stillpoint? What had he been seeking? Was it the solace so many of us seek? I knew he had done nothing malicious, nothing out of spite. The damage would have been much greater had that been the case. Was he just trying to find a quiet place?
My heart plummeted. Tears stung my eyes. Poor soul! was all I could think. What was it like to be held in the throes of another reality, I wondered. How could one expect to live a life of any quality in the grips of such a disorienting and disabling condition? I knew nothing about psychosis or schizophrenia, one of the forms psychosis can take, but I would soon find out.
At the time, I didn’t know that the word “schizophrenia” comes from Greek roots, “schizo” meaning split, and “phrene” meaning mind, coined in 1910 by Swiss psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler. It’s not a case of split or multiple personalities, nor dementia leading to mental deterioration. But it can lead to delusions, hallucinations, paranoia, depression, emotional withdrawal, problems with judgement, or other symptoms, varying with the individual.
When I saw Dan Gray there in that courtroom, I didn’t know much of anything about the condition, but I did feel ashamed of my ignorance and belittled by the jokes I had made. And mostly, I felt deep remorse that I participated in his being there. At the same time, I wondered how he could ever function safely in daily life when he could potentially pose a danger to himself or, less likely, to others. His future seemed bleak. I couldn’t imagine any good outcome for Dan Gray.
It wasn’t until years later that I would read Elyn Saks’s words about the potentially cruelest part of Gray’s future, and also of his recent past. Saks wrote, “One of the worst aspects of schizophrenia is the profound isolation—the constant awareness that you’re different, some sort of alien, not really human. Other people have flesh and bones, and insides made of organs and healthy living tissue. You are only a machine, with insides made of metal.”
That day in court, when my turn on the witness stand came, I first responded to questions from the prosecuting attorney about how I came to know Gray was on the property and what I had done in response. When asked about damages, I found myself minimizing them:
Q. What would be your best estimate of the amount of damage and/or used food, liquor, that type of thing?
A. A couple hundred dollars.
And after that, when asked by the defense attorney if I knew Gray, I responded with the only way I could think of to afford Gray even a modicum of respect:
Q. You’ve never seen him until today?
A. No, I haven’t seen the gentleman.
I was close to tears, but I didn’t want to react emotionally. In my mind, that could only make things worse for Dan Gray. I gave the facts I knew, but I did not want restitution of any kind. Mr. Gray would be going to Colorado Mental Health Institute at Pueblo, and for a very long time.
I didn’t know until looking into some of the literature that schizophrenia most often strikes men in their early twenties and women in their late twenties, and that it strikes men most often. Although it doesn’t often hit after age forty-five, it can. And it most often requires life-long treatment.
I didn’t know schizophrenia is associated with reduced life expectancy, that someone suffering from it could expect to live about fifteen years less than the general population, and also have a five to ten percent risk of suicide.
I found I didn’t know enough and wanted to know more. A friend then connected me with Dr. Claire Gibson, in her second year of residency at Yale Psychiatric Hospital. I asked Dr. Gibson how someone suffering from psychosis thinks, how their brain might work. “We still have a lot to understand about the psychotic brain,” she said. “But we know someone with a serious thought disorder is likely to have random, scattered thoughts—that they would be unable to connect A to B to C.”
Hearing Gray’s story, she found it unusual that he was able to find uninhabited land and execute all these plans—breaking into cabins and searching for water. Doing all that, she told me, showed a surprising amount of planning and organization.
Armed with more research sent by Dr. Gibson and her recommendation of the book by Elyn Saks, I continued to explore, learning about genetic, environmental, and physiological factors that contribute to psychosis and delusions. Of particular interest to me was how numerous studies have shown that neural circuits, structural arrangements of neurons and their interactions with each other when placed end to end, differ in healthy people from those with schizophrenia and people experiencing their first psychotic episode. With the latter, studies have shown distinct disruptions in the synchronization of neural circuits. It was a physical thing.
I also learned that genetic and early environmental risk factors, including trauma and invalidation, can disrupt brain development in ways that increase the risk of developing schizophrenia. And, once someone is in the throes of psychosis, confronting their delusions is counterproductive, serving only to strengthen the delusion’s hold on the person.
There is more, much more. And research continues to bring further insights into what causes people to develop psychosis and what happens in their brains when they do. So much remains to be done to understand and treat this heartbreaking disorder.
It’s possible to change locks, wash dishes, restore order to a house, and repair damage to a wall. But Dan Gray’s mind cannot so easily be mended. Now I think of him in the Colorado Mental Health Institute, of how he looked that day in court, and my heart aches for him. I feel chastened and grateful for a glimmer of understanding of this affliction, but I fervently wish that glimmer had not come at this man’s expense.
Yet, how are we to know what we don’t know? Perhaps it’s true, as some would say, that we can’t know what we haven’t experienced, those things we have yet to discover. But can we learn to recognize clues that we’re bumping up against the not-knowing? In Braiding Sweetgrass, scientist and member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation Robin Wall Kimmerer writes, “A teacher comes, they say, when you are ready. And if you ignore its presence, it will speak to you more loudly. But you have to be quiet to hear.”
I wish that I had been able to see beyond my jokes about Dan Gray’s claims, that I had been able to understand the roots of his suffering, and mostly, that he wasn’t “other” at all. But the teacher, Dan Gray’s presence in that courtroom, spoke loudly. And finally, I was quiet enough to hear.
REFERENCES
Arnold, K & Vakhrusheva, J. (2015). Resist the negation reflex: Minimizing reactance in psychotherapy of delusions. Psychosis, 8(2),1-6. https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17522439.2015.1095229
History of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia.com website. http://schizophrenia.com/history.htm#
Kimmerer, R. (2015). Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants. Milkweed Editions, Minneapolis.
McCutcheon, R. A., Marques, T.R., Howes, O. D. (2019). Schizophrenia—an overview. JAMA
Psychiatry.doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2019.3360
Saks, E. (2008) The Center Cannot Hold: My Journey Through Madness. Hachette Books,
New York.
An educator for more than four decades, Carol Ann Wilson’s work with public schools and higher education institutions focused on issues of democracy and social justice, as did her writing. As an educator, she was involved with students and adults dealing with mental illnesses, primarily depression and PTSD. It was a personal experience, however, with a person diagnosed with schizophrenia that led to a much deeper awareness of mental illnesses and the monumental challenges they bring. This encounter led her to write “House of Mirrors.” Her creative nonfiction also includes Still Point of the Turning World: The Life of Gia-fu Feng, which won Foreword Review’s Book of the Year Award. Her essays have appeared in Under the Gum Tree, The Write Launch, Wrath-Bearing Tree, and bookscover2cover and Unlimited Literature. Carol lives and writes in Boulder, Colorado. For more information, please see https://carolannwilson.info